Best Key Lime Pie in Cape Coral
Order Our Key Lime Pie in Cape Coral
Featured from our menu
- Kids
Kids Rib
- Kids
Kids Turkey
- BULK BBQ
Pickles
Fresh, cool, and crisp
- BULK BBQ
Pork by the Pound
Hand chopped Carolina pork BBQ

Classic Key Lime Pie
Finish your hearty barbecue meal with our refreshing Key Lime Pie right here in Cape Coral. This dessert features a tart, rich and creamy filling made with fresh squeezed key limes on a soft graham cracker cookie crust. Anyone who loves a classic citrus treat will thoroughly enjoy this sweet finish to their dinner. It provides the perfect bright contrast to savory smoked meats and hearty sides. If you are ordering for a group with diverse tastes, this pie pairs wonderfully alongside our Banana Pudding.
How to order
Enjoying dessert from Big Nicks BBQ is simple with our convenient dining options. You can easily select pickup to grab your sweet treat directly from our Cape Coral location. We also offer delivery straight to your door when you prefer to stay comfortably at home. If you are hosting a larger event, our catering services will gladly provide plenty of delicious dessert for all your hungry guests.

You might also like
Guests who love our Key Lime Pie also explore these other menu items.
- Banana Pudding (Pint)
- Collard Greens
- Hush Puppies
- Jalapeño Cheddar Sausage